The surge in popularity of small and compact crossover SUVs is undeniable. Car buyers are increasingly attracted to these vehicles for their generous cargo space, responsive performance, efficient automatic transmissions, and overall value. Manufacturers often highlight the reliability of crossovers, suggesting they offer the same dependability as traditional passenger cars. But with numerous options available, which crossovers truly stand out when maintenance and long-term reliability are your top priorities? We’ve meticulously examined the crossover market to pinpoint the most reliable models, ensuring you can make an informed decision.
Need help buying a used car?
Enter a VIN code to learn more about any vehicle!
Get report
How We Ranked the Most Reliable Crossover SUVs
Determining the reliability of a car model isn’t simply based on personal opinions or anecdotal evidence. Robust, professional dependability studies employ rigorous methodologies to assess the likelihood of future issues. To compile this list of the Most Reliable Crossover Suvs, we analyzed data from leading industry sources, including Consumer Reports, J.D. Power, What Car?, and other reputable studies. Our aim is to provide you with a data-backed guide to confidently choose a crossover that minimizes potential headaches and maximizes peace of mind.
The Most Reliable Crossover SUVs: Top 10 Ranked
10. Tesla Model Y
Source: garywfoto / Flickr
The Tesla Model Y, Tesla’s top-selling model, offers a taste of future-forward driving. While not without its imperfections, it presents a compelling option for those prioritizing a long electric range and cutting-edge, user-friendly technology.
Despite being recognized as one of the more reliable electric crossover SUVs, the Model Y, a relatively recent addition to the Tesla lineup, has encountered some challenges. In 2022, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) issued six recalls for the Model Y, primarily related to electrical system concerns.
However, a persistent issue for Model Y owners is the 12-volt battery system. Problems with this low-voltage battery can manifest in various ways. If you notice the vehicle’s alarm activating unexpectedly or the media control unit randomly restarting, it’s advisable to inspect the 12-volt battery’s condition.
9. Infiniti QX50
Source: RL GNZLZ / Flickr
The Infiniti QX50, admired for its striking design both inside and out, innovative engine technology, and capable performance, does face stiff competition in the luxury crossover segment.
A primary challenge for the QX50 is the high benchmark set by rivals, particularly Lexus, which consistently excels in reliability surveys. Nevertheless, the QX50 still offers commendable dependability.
J.D. Power awarded the QX50 a predicted reliability score of 77 out of 100. Although a newer model, owner feedback points to a potential issue with the CVT transmission. Some drivers have reported shifting delays, grinding noises, or abrupt jerking during acceleration.
8. Mitsubishi Outlander Sport
Source: Rutger van der Maar / Flickr
In theory, the Mitsubishi Outlander Sport (known as ASX in Europe) has the potential to be a leading compact crossover. It boasts a respectable cargo area, an efficient engine, and a user-friendly interior layout. However, its modern features, notably the infotainment system, can feel dated compared to newer competitors.
While some may criticize Mitsubishi’s conservative approach to technology and features, this can be seen as an advantage for buyers prioritizing reliable, no-frills transportation. Less complex electronics often translate to improved reliability ratings for Mitsubishi vehicles. RepairPal gave the Outlander Sport a reliability rating of 4.0 out of 5.0, positioning Mitsubishi 7th out of 26 brands in the compact crossover category.
A notable reliability concern for the Mitsubishi Outlander Sport is its susceptibility to corrosion. While this may not be a significant issue in warmer climates, rust can become a problem after several winters, particularly in regions with road salt usage like the Eastern US or Canada.
7. BMW X1
Source: Kārlis Dambrāns / Flickr
The second generation BMW X1 marked a shift for the smallest BMW crossover, moving from a rear-wheel-drive configuration to a more cost-effective and, for most drivers, safer front-wheel-drive layout.
The BMW X1 has shown improvements across various aspects compared to its predecessor, including performance, fuel efficiency, interior space, and notably, reliability.
In the What Car? vehicle dependability study, the BMW X1 achieved an impressive reliability rating of 98.4%, establishing it as one of the most reliable vehicles in its class. Furthermore, studies indicate that BMW’s latest generation of turbocharged engines has addressed previous issues related to oil consumption and timing chains. However, owners have reported instances of premature wear in brake pads, lower control arms, and bushings.
6. Mercedes-Benz GLC
Source: Rutger van der Maar / Flickr
This highly-regarded luxury crossover has garnered widespread acclaim for its spacious cabin, advanced technology features, and diverse engine options, including gasoline, diesel, and hybrid powertrains.
As one of Mercedes-Benz’s most popular models, the GLC also boasts strong reliability. Over recent years, the Mercedes-Benz GLC has consistently performed well in the TÜV Report, a German survey evaluating the technical condition of vehicles. For vehicles aged two to three years, the significant defect rate for the Mercedes GLC is remarkably low at just 1.5 percent.
The most commonly reported issues with the GLC involve brake pad squealing and accelerated tire wear. Many owners have noted that their tires require replacement between 20,000 and 30,000 miles.
5. Lexus UX
Source: Kārlis Dambrāns / Flickr
The Lexus UX serves as an accessible entry point into the Lexus ownership experience. While positioned as the “entry-level” Lexus crossover, this compact model has notable strengths.
Its hybrid powertrain offers fuel efficiency, and its refined handling makes navigating congested urban environments effortless. The UX also features an interior that surpasses the quality of rivals like the Audi Q3 and BMW X1.
However, the Lexus UX’s most compelling attribute is its exceptional reliability. According to What Car? research, only 6% of Lexus vehicles experience problems, and the UX crossover outperforms even within this context. Achieving a remarkable reliability rating of 99.8%, it emerged as the top-scoring hybrid in the study.
While most UX models are trouble-free, the most frequently reported issue across the Lexus range is failures of the 12-volt battery, which can impact both the hybrid powertrain and all-electric systems. Lexus also continues to address ongoing issues with its infotainment systems, with even newer models experiencing freezing or erratic behavior.
4. Buick Encore
Source: Rodrigo Kurmen Figueroa / Flickr
Compact crossovers have effectively replaced less appealing hatchbacks in the market. Models like the Buick Encore offer an elevated driving position, increased ground clearance, a spacious interior, and a more rugged aesthetic. For the Encore, and Buick in general, dependability is a key selling point.
Buick has consistently ranked high in the J.D. Power Initial Quality Study for years, highlighting the brand’s commitment to enhancing quality and reliability. The Buick Encore crossover has received particularly high ratings within the small crossover category.
Despite its strong reliability reputation, the Encore isn’t entirely without fault: some owners have reported experiencing inadequate engine power, often attributed to a malfunctioning throttle body or sensor. Additionally, the check engine light can sometimes illuminate without an apparent cause. Should this occur, using a diagnostic scan tool can help pinpoint the underlying issue.
3. Honda HR-V
Source: The NRMA / Flickr
While the Honda HR-V may not be the most exhilarating crossover on the market, it stands out as one of the most practical and intelligently designed vehicles available. Like other Honda models, the HR-V features the innovative Magic Seat system, allowing the rear seat cushions to fold upwards to accommodate tall items – a unique and highly useful feature in this class.
However, the most compelling aspect of the HR-V is its exceptional reliability. RepairPal awarded the Honda HR-V a perfect reliability rating of 5.0. Furthermore, RepairPal estimates the HR-V’s average annual repair costs to be remarkably low, at just $301 per year.
Some HR-V owners have noted that the body paint can be thin and prone to chipping, potentially leading to corrosion issues over time. Transmission problems have also been reported. If you notice hesitant gear shifting or unusual grinding noises from the transmission, immediate inspection is recommended.
2. Mazda CX-5
Source: RL GNZLZ / Flickr
Mazda consistently emphasizes the driver-car connection in their vehicles. While the Mazda CX-5 isn’t as nimble as the MX-5 roadster, it delivers an engaging driving experience, feeling surprisingly athletic for a crossover SUV.
Moreover, the CX-5 is recognized as one of the most reliable vehicles in its segment. In the Consumer Reports dependability survey, the Mazda CX-5 secured the second-place ranking in the Compact Sport Utility Vehicle category. The CX-5 also earned a top five-star rating for predicted reliability.
To date, the most commonly reported issue with the Mazda CX-5 involves the daytime running LED lights or turn signals, which are known to flicker or fail prematurely. Mazda has acknowledged that sulfur released from the sealing gaskets on the light’s wiring connectors can corrode the circuit.
1. Toyota RAV4
Source: crash71100 / Flickr
The Toyota RAV4 is a global bestseller for Toyota, appealing to a wide range of buyers. Passengers appreciate the ample rear-seat space and intuitive infotainment system, while drivers commend the engine performance and, above all, its renowned reliability.
According to a reliability survey by What Car?, the RAV4 is consistently ranked among the most dependable vehicles available for purchase. It also achieves high scores in predicted reliability ratings from J.D. Power, and RepairPal has consistently placed it among the top 3 most reliable crossover SUVs.
Despite its exceptional reliability ratings, the RAV4 has been known to experience issues with the evaporative system vapor canisters, which may require replacement. Another common complaint from Toyota RAV4 owners is related to inaccurate fuel gauges, potentially leading to miscalculations of remaining driving range. Beyond these relatively minor issues, the RAV4 stands out as one of the most reliable vehicles you can own.
Understanding Crossover SUVs
Why is it called a crossover car?
The term “crossover” aptly describes this vehicle type, as it “crosses over” and blends the elevated seating position and spaciousness of a traditional SUV with the comfort, driving dynamics, technology, and fuel efficiency of a passenger car.
Depending on market classifications, crossovers are generally categorized into two size segments: subcompact and compact.
Subcompact crossovers typically measure under 4.4 meters in length and often share their underlying platform with small hatchbacks. For example, the Honda HR-V shares a platform with the Honda Fit/Jazz, and the Nissan Juke is based on the Nissan Micra platform.
The more popular compact crossover segment generally includes vehicles ranging from 4.3 to 4.7 meters in length. This size variation reflects the attempt to accommodate both five and seven-seat configurations across different price points. Size and price differences are evident in popular models such as the Audi Q3, Toyota RAV4, and Nissan Rogue/X-Trail.
What are the advantages of a crossover vehicle?
Crossover SUVs offer drivers a number of benefits, including a higher, more upright seating position (enhancing visibility), a roomy cabin, strong safety ratings, and a range of practical features.
Built on passenger car platforms, crossovers generally drive more like cars than traditional SUVs. The driving experience in a crossover is often comparable to driving a taller station wagon.
Compared to larger SUVs, crossovers are significantly more maneuverable in urban environments and tight parking spaces. They provide a more comfortable ride and offer better handling characteristics than many SUVs, making them well-suited for daily commuting.
While crossovers may sacrifice some of the off-road capability and towing capacity of traditional SUVs, their widespread popularity demonstrates that many car buyers are willing to prioritize these trade-offs in exchange for the benefits crossovers offer.
Ensuring a Smooth Used Crossover SUV Purchase
Big or small – every vehicle has a history
Enhance your used vehicle buying experience by taking advantage of resources like our used vehicle buying guide. An even more direct and effective step is to obtain a comprehensive vehicle history report and let us handle the research for you.
A detailed carVertical vehicle history report provides valuable insights into a vehicle’s past, alerting you to potential hidden issues. By simply entering a car’s VIN into our VIN decoder, you can access information about:
- Original factory specifications and equipment
- History of any past damages
- Theft records (if applicable)
- Verified odometer readings (detecting mileage rollback)
- Vehicle’s financial and legal status
- Current market value, and much more.
Protect yourself from potential scams and make informed decisions in the used car market.
Check your VIN
Avoid costly problems by checking a vehicle’s history. Get a report instantly!
Frequently Asked Questions
Article by
Aivaras Grigelevičius
Aivaras’s fascination with cars began in early childhood. This passion for vehicles and the automotive world evolved into a career as an automotive journalist. Since then, Aivaras has contributed to numerous publications, covering a wide spectrum of automotive topics. He holds a particular fondness for vehicles bearing the Alfa Romeo marque.
