The 2024 Bmw Z4 stands out as a compelling option in the luxury sports car market, especially for those who prioritize driving pleasure and open-top thrills. Currently, behind the wheel of the 2025 BMW Z4 M40i, finished in the striking Thundernight Metallic, the allure of this roadster is undeniable. Equipped with the newly introduced six-speed manual transmission as part of the Handschalter package, it amplifies the joy of top-down driving in perfect weather. While a full review is on the horizon, it’s crucial to address a key question: why does the Z4 deliver a more rewarding sports car experience compared to its platform sibling, the Toyota GR Supra?
The Z4 has consistently impressed since its 2020 launch, in both inline-six and four-cylinder guises. Previous experiences have already highlighted a preference for the Z4 over the Supra for various compelling reasons. Interestingly, concerns about the shared platform between the Supra and Z4 seem to have faded, with both cars establishing distinct identities. Yet, revisiting the Z4 reinforces the conviction that it holds a definitive edge over its Japanese counterpart.
Related: 2024 BMW Z4: A Comprehensive Guide On Features, Specs, And Pricing
The Authentic BMW Engine Experience
One of the most persuasive arguments for choosing the 2024 BMW Z4 lies in embracing the genuine BMW engine. If you’re drawn to BMW’s acclaimed B58 engine, it naturally follows to opt for a BMW vehicle. It’s important to clarify that the Toyota Supra is an exceptional sports car, arguably even more visually striking to some than the Z4. However, fundamentally, it isn’t a Toyota engine at its heart.
The B58, a 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-six, is a masterpiece of BMW engineering. In the Z4 M40i, it unleashes a potent 382 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque. Even with the engaging six-speed manual transmission, this agile two-seater achieves 0 to 60 mph in approximately four seconds, demonstrating remarkable speed and responsiveness.
Another significant advantage of the 2024 BMW Z4 is the continued availability of the base 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine, producing 255 hp and 295 lb-ft of torque. Notably, this engine option is no longer offered in the Supra for the 2025 model year. The four-cylinder Z4 presents an excellent choice for drivers who prioritize balanced chassis dynamics and optimal weight distribution over sheer acceleration. The lighter engine contributes to a more nimble and agile feel. It’s a missed opportunity that BMW doesn’t pair this engine with a manual transmission, which could further enhance its appeal to purists.
Convertible Appeal and Enhanced Livability
As driving preferences evolve, the allure of a convertible sports car like the 2024 BMW Z4 becomes increasingly apparent. There’s an unparalleled joy in lowering the top and connecting directly with the environment, especially on pleasant days. This open-air experience alone is a strong differentiator favoring the Z4 over the hardtop Supra.
Lowering the Z4’s soft-top also enhances the auditory experience, allowing a fuller appreciation of the B58 engine’s exhaust note. While some engine sounds are digitally augmented through the audio system, the authentic exhaust note still contributes significantly to the driving excitement.
Furthermore, the 2024 BMW Z4 distinguishes itself through superior daily usability compared to the GR Supra, primarily due to its versatile drive modes. While the Supra offers a single, Toyota-tuned Sport mode, the Z4 provides a selection of Sport, Comfort, and Eco Pro modes. This range of options allows for greater adaptability, making the Z4 more refined and manageable for everyday driving scenarios. Additionally, the Supra is known for considerable wind buffeting when windows are down. The Z4 effectively eliminates this issue, even with the roof down, contributing to a more comfortable and enjoyable ride.
While the base four-cylinder 2024 BMW Z4 carries a similar price tag to the entry-level inline-six Toyota Supra, opting for the Z4 M40i will represent a price increase compared to a fully-equipped Toyota GR Supra Premium. BMW’s optional packages can further elevate the price. The Z4’s premium positioning reflects its BMW lineage and features. Ultimately, the 2024 BMW Z4 delivers a more complete and rewarding sports car package, justifying its position as the preferred choice for discerning drivers.
